Saturday, October 18, 2008

1st grade conversations

Lucinda and I have been talking about social situations in 1st grade, and I liked the dialogue enough to share it. One background detail: In Japan, children often settle disputes by playing "rock, paper, scissors," or "jankenpoi."

On Friday night, Lucinda told me that she and a friend, Anathea, disagreed about how they would play tag at recess. Lucinda preferred "fairy tag," and Anathea wanted "zebra tag." So they did jankenpoi and Lucinda won repeatedly; Anathea got upset. What, Lucinda asked me, should she do in that situation? I told her to think it over and we'd discuss the next day.

Yesterday (Saturday) I took her to a clothing store and lunch in Omotesando, while Blaine took Arno to the park to play baseball. On the train, Lucinda and I talked things over.

Me: Did you think about your choices in the situation with Anathea? What could you do when a friend is upset about losing?

Lucinda: I could tell her that the next time, I'd be "scissors" and she should be "rock."

Me: That's a good idea. What else could you do?

Lucinda: I could tell her that I'd be "rock" and she could be "paper."

Me: Okay, you could set it up so that she would win and feel better. What else could you do?

Lucinda: I could say that we could play zebra tag first and then fairy tag.

Me: What else?

Lucinda: Well, since I won, I could tell her that we could play fairy tag and then zebra tag.

Children are so literal sometimes, but they also eventually assess the big picture.

No comments: